FNAF Into the Pit – All Endings Guide

FNAF Into the Pit has a variety of endings, with more than half of them all being brand new endings for this game’s adaptation of the novel.

After all, Into the Pit was originally part of the Fazbear Frights novels based on Five Nights at Freddy’s. As a game, however, they can use the story’s newfound interactivity to let us get alternate endings. Some of them are nicer than the official ending, while others are… definitely not quite as happy.

In this guide, we’ll tell you how to get all of the endings in FNAF Into the Pit. Just be warned that there will obviously be spoilers for the game in this guide.

All Endings | Five Nights at Freddy’s: Into the Pit Guide

See Ya, Dad – Early Bad Ending

You can get this ending as early as Night 1 after diving into the pit at Jeff’s Pizza and ending up in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria. Simply head over to the Entrance, which is on the leftmost part of the pizzeria as shown on the map.

Once there, just leave Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria by going through the gate on the left side of the room. Oswald will leave, abandoning his own father and the other kids to their fates. Yet, Oswald himself seems unsure of where to even go from here… and then the credits roll. You’ll get the “See Ya, Dad” achievement for this ending.

You can get this ending on multiple nights, and it’s particularly easy to get it accidentally since there’s no prompt asking if you wish to leave. However, there’s another more involved bad ending in Five Nights At Freddy’s: Into the Pit as well. Do be warned, there will be more spoilers from here on out!

What Am I – Unique Game Over Ending

You can get this ending near the end of Night 5. You’ll have to fight off Spring Bonnie as you attempt to escape the ball pit one last time with Oswald’s Dad. To get the ending, simply fail the QTE when you get grabbed by Spring Bonnie.

The screen will fade to black and Oswald will reappear on the stage in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria. Walk to the right to meet Spring Bonnie again and get a short scene, concluding the sequence. You’ll unlock the “What Am I” achievement and get taken to the Game Over screen, letting you retry the QTE.

Pit-Y Party – 1-Star Ending

As we’ve covered in our Bad Ending guide, this is the default ending of the game. You’ll get this ending as long as you fail to collect all of Dad’s items during your playthrough, with the Strange Photo being particularly important to avoid if you actually want to get this ending.

For some reason, having just Dad’s Name Tag has unlocked the Strange Photo for some people. This should require all 5 of Dad’s items, so you should make sure to at least ignore Dad’s Name Tag for this ending.

Just so that you know how to avoid them, Dad’s Name Tag is in the right bottom corner of the Storage Room on Night 5. You’ll get the Strange Photo automatically later in the story as long as you have Dad’s Name Tag in your inventory, which will get you a good ending instead. In short, avoid poking around the Storage Room on Night 5 if you want this bad ending.

Having both of those items in your inventory will give you a better ending. If you’ve already picked both of them up, you’ll need to load a previous save or restart the game to get this bad ending.

Besides that, you simply need to complete the game’s story by rescuing Oswald’s dad while avoiding those items. Oswald and his dad will both escape the ball pit, but things won’t end quite as nicely for Oswald as he thinks. Watch the ending and the credits will roll!

This counts as the 1-Star ending for the game so you will get the “Pit-y Party” achievement after the credits.

Jeff? – 2-Star Ending

As we covered in its dedicated article, in order to get the good ending in FNAF Into the Pit you must:

• Collect all items related to Oswald’s Dad
• Collect the Strange Photo that can be found during Night 5

You will need to have all of these items in your inventory before your final encounter with Yellow Bonnie next to the ball pit. The encounter with Yellow Bonnie will happen after you find Dad in the control room. If you haven’t found him already, check out our guide on how to find Dad.

All Items Related to Oswald’s Dad

There are a total of 5 different Dad items you need to have on you to trigger the game’s good ending. They are:

• Dad’s Wallet – Found on the floor in the Backstage room, starting from Night 1.
• Photo of Oswald – In the Storage room by the presents on the left top corner. Available starting from Night 2.
• Family Vacation Photo – On the floor of the Kitchen, starting from Night 3.
• Dad’s Wedding Ring – On the rightmost side of the Security room. Becomes available on Night 4.
• Dad’s Name Tag – In the front right corner of the Storage room, only on Night 5.

All 5 of these items can be found in specific locations at Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria all throughout the game’s story.

Strange Photo

Other than the 5 Dad related items, you will also need to collect the Strange Photo. So where can the Strange Photo be found?

You can find the Strange Photo inside the Party Room after you unlock it and rescue the trapped girl inside it. The photo will be on the ground next to the vent you need to go through to get to Dad.

This photo will only spawn if you have all 5 Dad items in your inventory. So before going into the Party Room, make sure you have all 5 Dad items on you. Additionally, the photo will also only spawn during Night 5 of the game.

With all 5 Dad items and the Strange Photo in your inventory, defeating Yellow Bonnie will give you the game’s good ending. FNAF Into the Pit is a pretty short game, so you can easily play the game again if you want some other ending.

Family Fun Night – 3-Star Ending

The final ending of the FNAF Into the Pit is the happiest of all endings, which also means it’s going to require the most work to get. You’ll need to meet all of the criteria for the 2-Star Ending, as well as make sure that you complete all Arcade games and Secret Minigames.

Arcade Machines

To begin, you’ll need to complete the Arcade games at Jeff’s Pizza. The machines are broken, however, so you’ll need to find parts to fix them. Additionally, you’ll need to complete the special score criteria for every machine. These are all the machines, where to find their parts, and their score requirements:

• SOLVE THE PUZZLE – Its part is the Puzzle Matrix, found at The Mill since Night 1. Simply complete its puzzle to win.
• FAST FOOD INVADER – You can find its part, the Space-Age Speakers, at any time on the floor in Jeff’s Pizza’s Arcade. You need to score 5000 points.
• SHOOT THE SPACE BALLOONS – Find its Power Supply in the Storage room at Jeff’s Pizza at any time. Get a score of 10000 points.
• DELIVER THE PIZZA – Its part is the Electron Gun, which is available from the start in the Party Hallway at Jeff’s Pizza. You must get 2000 points.
• COLLECT THE HATS – Get its Control Panel from the table in the Party Hallway at Jeff’s Pizza. Get all 6 hats to win.
• PIZZA ROLLER – Requires the Wooden Balls, which are near the ball pit at Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria. You need to get 800 points.
• RESCUE THE CHILDREN – You can get the Token Slot for it from the Basement in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria, starting from Night 1. Escape with all 4 kids to complete it.
• HEFTIN’ WITH HELPULES – Requires the Weight Resistance Mechanism found in the Basement at Oswald’s House starting from Night 2. Get 10 points to win.
• Ticket Counter – Found during Night 3 on the far-left part of the Dining Area in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria.
• Voucher Validator – Found during Day 3 in the second classroom after school.

Secret Minigames

After the painstaking process of fixing and completing the Arcade machines, you’ll now have to find and complete the three secret minigames in FNAF Into the Pit and see all their endings. These minigames are all references to other Fazbear Frights stories, so they’re a treat for longtime fans! Here’s how to start all of them:

• Count the Ways (Party Cleanup) – Go to the Dining Area in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria and interact with the candy machine a ridiculous amount of times. It requires around 100 interactions, so just keep clicking on it until the minigame pops up.
• Fetch (Pick Up Balloons) – Before saving Oswald’s Dad on Night 5, earn enough Tickets from Arcade machines to redeem all of the Prize Vouchers. You should have gotten them naturally as you completed the previous step of this ending, considering the score requirements. Once you’ve redeemed all Prize Vouchers, go to the Arcade in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria (not Jeff’s Pizza) and interact with the Prize Machine to get the minigame.
• To Be Beautiful (Grant Her Wish) – During Night 5, go to the Secret Room behind the Arcade’s Prize Machine in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria. Use Dad’s Phone to dial Mom’s Number (5555683) and the minigame will automatically start.

Complete all of these Secret Minigames, the Arcade Machines, then collect all of Dad’s Items and the Strange Photo. This will reward Osward with the truly happy ending he deserves after all his hard work, and you’ll get the “Family Fun Night” achievement upon beating the game.

We hope this guide helped you see all possible endings to Oswald’s tale in FNAF Into The Pit!